
Apple to face Paris trial in 2027 over iPhone repair limits
Apple will face a Paris criminal trial in 2027 over alleged iPhone repair restrictions covering 24 models sold from November 2021 through July 2024, with hearings set for February and June.
- By
- Sophie Lindqvist
- Filed
- Channel
- Consumer Tech
- Read
- 3 min read
By Sophie Lindqvist
Apple faces a Paris criminal trial over iPhone repair restrictions, with a first procedural hearing set for Feb. 25, 2027. The case covers 24 iPhone models sold between Nov. 17, 2021, and July 23, 2024.
What does the case cover?
French campaign group Halte à l’obsolescence programmée (HOP), which brought the original complaint, said on Tuesday, Nov. 17 that Apple will appear before the Paris tribunal correctionnel, France’s criminal court for offenses. The tribunal will hold its first procedural hearing on Feb. 25, 2027, followed by several days of pleadings in June 2027.
HOP says the proceeding will be France’s first trial specifically addressing the offense of obstructing repair and refurbishment. That description remains the group’s claim. No court has ruled on the allegations.
How does Apple allegedly restrict repairs?
HOP’s case centers on serialization, also called pairing. Its technical account says:
- Screens, batteries, camera modules and some biometric sensors carry serial numbers.
- Those numbers tie each component to an iPhone’s logic board.
- The phone flags or restricts a replaced part that fails validation through Apple’s online tool.
HOP alleges that this restriction can cause malfunctions even when the replacement is an identical original part, whether that part is new or has been taken from another iPhone. The group’s December 2022 complaint cited an iPhone XR whose replacement screen stopped being recognized under iOS 16. The complaint supplies the example, not a court finding.
Which law is at issue?
The case relies on Article L441-3 of the French Consumer Code, which has applied since 2021 under France’s anti-waste law and prohibits techniques that block repair outside approved channels. It also covers software and any obstruction to refurbishment outside a manufacturer’s approved channels.
The Paris prosecutor’s office opened its investigation in 2023. Published reports do not state what penalty prosecutors will seek. The tribunal has not decided whether Apple’s challenged serialization techniques fall within the prohibited category. That threshold remains untested.
How has Apple responded?
“We firmly contest these unfounded allegations,” Apple said in a statement carried by French reports. The company added that it would keep innovating. The statement is a denial, not a judicial finding. The published account gives no technical comparison between Apple’s current validation rules and HOP’s examples.
Apple says it has limited serialization on new iPhones since 2022, permits third parties to validate some repairs, and launched its Self Service Repair program in Europe in late 2022. These are Apple’s own statements. No figures in the account quantify their effect across the 24 models sold during the 2021–2024 period.
What does the earlier case establish?
This case is separate from HOP’s 2017 complaint about software updates that slowed older iPhones, a dispute that ended in 2020 without a trial. Apple agreed to pay a €25 million fine in a settlement. That earlier settlement did not determine the outcome of the present repair case.
HOP estimates Apple sells about 4 million smartphones a year in France, although the published account gives neither a revenue total nor an estimation method for that sales figure. The estimate does not show how many of those phones fall within the 24 covered models. It provides scale, not case-specific unit or financial exposure.
What could the June 2027 hearings change?
The June 2027 pleadings will test HOP’s technical account against Apple’s account of post-2022 repair policies. A ruling could determine whether iPhone pairing can lawfully restrict independent repair and refurbishment in France. For Apple, the exposure includes an unknown penalty and a market where HOP estimates annual smartphone sales of about 4 million.
Source: mlq.ai
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
News editor covering money, funding and market shifts around Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.
1,076 articles
Related articles
apple-reaches-discovery-impasse-with-samsung-epic-and-oura
Apple reaches discovery impasse with Samsung, Epic and Oura
five-days-with-apple-s-2-000-iphone-duo-a-reluctant-convert-s-verdict
Five Days With Apple's $2,000 iPhone Duo: A Reluctant Convert's Verdict
apple-intelligence-registered-in-china-for-macs-and-ipads
Apple Intelligence registered in China for Macs and iPads
binance-warns-ios-flaw-can-expose-crypto-seed-phrases
Binance Warns iOS Flaw Can Expose Crypto Seed Phrases

