
Cantwell Accuses Commerce of Letting AI Chips Flow to China
Sen. Maria Cantwell says Commerce let advanced AI chips flow to China-linked firms and warns Lutnick's $1.2B Nvidia tie creates a 'perverse financial incentive.'
- By
- Rebecca Stone
- Filed
- Channel
- Chips & Policy
- Read
- 4 min read
Sen. Maria Cantwell accused the Commerce Department on Sunday, Nov. 15, of letting advanced U.S. AI chips reach China-linked companies, and she pressed Secretary Howard Lutnick to enforce export law before President Trump meets Xi Jinping on Thursday, Nov. 19.
In a letter first reported by CNBC and The Verge, Cantwell — the Washington Democrat who ranks as the Senate Commerce Committee's top minority member — wrote that Commerce "has resisted efforts to restrict companies flagged as national security threats, weakened safeguards, and left open pathways for the PRC to train advanced AI models."
The stakes are straightforward. AI accelerators, dominated by Nvidia's product lines, are the scarce input for training frontier models in China. Export controls are the main lever Washington has. Cantwell argues the lever isn't being pulled.
What did the letter say?
"Despite clear authority from Congress, the Department of Commerce has allowed advanced AI chips to flow through companies with ties to the People's Republic of China," Cantwell wrote, adding that "these failures to carry out the law help give away America's technology advantage in AI."
She called on Lutnick to use the Export Control Reform Act of 2018 — the statute that gives Commerce its licensing authority — to stop chips from reaching barred companies.
The Commerce Department did not immediately respond to CNBC's request for comment on Monday.
What enforcement failures did she cite?
According to The Verge, the letter lists several:
- Commerce did not act on warnings from White House and intelligence officials to restrict Megaspeed's access to AI chips, ahead of reports that former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang had a relationship with Alice Huang, a former Megaspeed executive U.S. officials suspect of passing information to China. Megaspeed says Alice Huang left the company in August 2025.
- Alibaba and ByteDance have used Nvidia chips through overseas data centers.
- A loophole allowing restricted companies to obtain U.S. AI technology through subsidiaries was extended rather than closed.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said last week that the Megaspeed blacklisting stalled because Commerce "has the pen." The New York Times reported on Nov. 15 that Lutnick pushed for narrower rules on overseas data centers serving Chinese customers.
Where's the conflict of interest claim?
Cantwell's sharpest charge touches Lutnick's wallet. Cantor Fitzgerald — the firm Lutnick led and that his sons now control — held $1.2 billion of Nvidia stock at the time of his nomination, she wrote.
She also flagged the administration's 25% fee on certain Nvidia chips sold to China, saying it could create "a perverse financial incentive to approve exports of sensitive American technology."
"America's national security and AI leadership cannot be compromised by family business interests or a policy that generates federal revenue from exporting technology critical to our competitive edge," Cantwell wrote.
CNBC reported last week that Cantor held 1.81 million Nvidia shares worth $362 million at the end of June.
How much pressure is building on Commerce?
Quite a lot, and from both parties.
Senate Banking Committee Chair Tim Scott, a South Carolina Republican, has summoned Jensen Huang and Lutnick to testify in December. Commerce spokesperson Kristen Eichamer said last week that Lutnick has agreed to appear. Sens. Elizabeth Warren and Chris Coons set a Nov. 17 deadline for Lutnick, Secretary of State Marco Rubio and White House Chief of Staff Stephen Miller to confirm they ordered Nvidia export records preserved.
Lawmakers in both parties are also moving toward tighter AI chip export rules.
"The Administration must account for its failure to enforce these protections and take immediate action to prevent America's most sensitive technology from strengthening our adversaries," Cantwell wrote in closing.
Does the White House have a rival plan?
It may. The Wall Street Journal reported on Sunday that the administration plans to name Nvidia and other U.S. AI companies "national champions" to help them expand overseas — a commercial-expansion track running alongside, and perhaps against, the enforcement track Cantwell demands.
With Huang and Lutnick now scheduled to testify in December, and Trump's Xi meeting set for Nov. 19, the question of who decides which Nvidia chips reach China — and who profits from that decision — moves from letters to hearings.
Source: mlq.ai
More from Rebecca Stone
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.
1,036 articles
Related articles
u-s-signals-easing-export-controls-with-offer-of-ai-chips-to-china-f7ed0dd9
U.S. Signals Easing Export Controls With Offer of AI Chips to China
us-authorities-charge-california-man-over-ai-chip-sales-to-china-be559d5a
US Authorities Charge California Man Over AI Chip Sales to China
china-asks-us-to-ease-ai-chip-export-controls-in-trade-talks-0c34fafe
China Asks US to Ease AI Chip Export Controls in Trade Talks
fbi-arrests-tech-executive-accused-of-smuggling-300m-in-ai-chips-to-china-3045c143
FBI Arrests Tech Executive Accused of Smuggling $300M in AI Chips to China



