
GPU Rental Data Undercuts Burry's $176 Billion Depreciation Warning
Rising rents for older NVIDIA GPUs challenge Michael Burry's $176 billion depreciation warning, but Vera Rubin supply and stretched balance sheets keep the accounting debate open.
- By
- Sophie Lindqvist
- Filed
- Channel
- AI & Compute
- Read
- 3 min read
Rental prices for older NVIDIA GPUs are rising, not collapsing, according to Silicon Data CEO Carmen Li — and that single data point cuts against Michael Burry's claim that the AI boom hides $176 billion of understated depreciation.
Burry has spent the past year arguing the AI buildout rests on a flattering accounting choice. In his Substack, Cassandra Unchained, he called stretched server and GPU useful-life assumptions "one of the more common frauds of the modern era." He estimated the industry could understate depreciation by $176 billion between 2026 and 2028. The claim is specific. The counter-evidence is now equally specific.
What does the rental market show?
Silicon Data publishes daily benchmarks for on-demand GPU rental rates. That gives it a direct view of what compute actually costs. In a Yahoo Finance interview with Deirdre Bosa, founder and CEO Carmen Li said older GPUs are holding value better than expected, with rental prices for certain older chips rising rather than collapsing as newer generations arrive.
Burry's thesis, strictly read, concerns accounting lives and reported earnings. It leaves room for older GPUs to retain commercial value. The rental data tests a key assumption underneath it: that NVIDIA's 12- to 18-month product cycle shortens the real economic life of each generation.
NVIDIA's own numbers point the same direction. On the August 26 earnings call, interim CEO and former finance chief Kress said NVIDIA compute is "fully utilized across every cloud we serve" and that supply should stay a constraint "at least through the end of fiscal year '28."
Why the depreciation question matters now
The debate lands amid unusual turbulence at NVIDIA (NASDAQ:NVDA). Shares closed at $162.85 on November 13, down 26.41% over the past month. Jensen Huang resigned as CEO amid disclosures about personal relationships. The board appointed Kress interim CEO this week. Investors are asking whether AI spending can hold up without him.
The accounting mechanics are straightforward. Buyers of NVIDIA processors spread the cost over each chip's estimated useful life. A longer schedule means a smaller yearly expense and higher reported profit. Microsoft (NASDAQ:MSFT) and Alphabet (NASDAQ:GOOGL) have moved certain server classes to four to six years. Burry argues NVIDIA's fast product cadence means today's earnings borrow from tomorrow's losses.
NVIDIA's fiscal second-quarter results show why hyperscalers keep buying. Revenue reached $96.221 billion, with Data Center revenue of $89.023 billion, up 117% year over year, per the company's release. NVIDIA still ships Hopper parts two generations back. Huang said on the call that an AI agent needs 15 to 100 times the compute of a human user, and that a deployed system "will be preserved and useful and productive for a lot longer."
Where Burry still has a point
Rents measure current earning power only. Resale value, book value, and lifetime profitability are separate questions. Today's pricing also reflects a shortage that could ease. Kress said the Vera Rubin platform delivers 35 times lower token costs relative to Grace Blackwell Ultra. Once that supply arrives in volume, demand for older chips could weaken.
NVIDIA has also taken on more risk to sustain the expansion. Supply commitments reached $279 billion. Guarantee obligations for AI cloud partners are capped at $108.5 billion. Days sales outstanding stretched to 60 days from 45 days. Each figure comes from company disclosures, not analyst models.
Which numbers settle the argument?
Three data sets will decide it, and none has arrived yet:
- Rental indexes: whether older-chip rents hold once Vera Rubin supply catches up.
- Hyperscaler filings: any change to server useful-life estimates in quarterly disclosures.
- NVIDIA's next report: results against guidance of $108.0 billion, plus or minus 2%, in revenue and gross margins of 74.0%, with any comment on utilization under interim leadership.
The stock trades at a P/E of 33, so the market already prices in durable demand. If rents fall sharply after the next product ramp, Burry's warning gains weight. If they hold, the case for longer depreciation schedules gets stronger.
Source: 247wallst.com
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
News editor covering money, funding and market shifts around Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.
1,004 articles
Related articles
burry-s-176-billion-warning-nvidia-s-real-risk-is-not-huang
Burry's $176 Billion Warning: Nvidia's Real Risk Is Not Huang
nvidia-claims-a-decade-of-payback-from-its-ai-chips-f50ac918
Nvidia Claims a Decade of Payback From Its AI Chips
wall-street-pushes-back-on-nvidia-s-500-billion-chip-backed-financing-plan-87039951
Wall Street Pushes Back on Nvidia's $500 Billion Chip-Backed Financing Plan
microsoft-walks-away-from-oracle-gpus-a-176-billion-depreciation-test
Microsoft Walks Away From Oracle GPUs: A $176 Billion Depreciation Test


