
NAND Spot Prices Fall 20% as DRAM Lawsuit Survives Micron's Exit Bid
BofA sees NAND spot prices down 20% since October as a DRAM price-fixing suit against Micron, Samsung and SK hynix survives dismissal, with Micron due to report December 16.
- By
- Nathan Brooks
- Filed
- Channel
- Memory & Storage
- Read
- 4 min read
NAND spot prices have fallen roughly 20% since mid-to-late October, according to BofA estimates cited by the Seoul Economic Daily. That number landed on Micron Technology in the same week a federal judge refused to dismiss a DRAM price-coordination lawsuit against the company, Samsung Electronics and SK hynix.
The ruling keeps the case alive without establishing any liability for the three memory makers. The suit targets all three companies and centers on how DRAM prices were set. For now, it is a legal overhang rather than a balance-sheet event.
How Hard Did the Stock Get Hit?
Micron shares fell 3.8% in premarket trading to €679.60, under pressure from both the court news and a broad selloff in chip names. The retreat was sector-wide, not company-specific.
Reuters had already reported Micron losses on Friday as semiconductor shares weakened, with investors reacting to uncertainty surrounding Nvidia. Micron shed 5% in that session. The Philadelphia Semiconductor Index dropped 5.1%. AP described a wide technology selloff amid mounting worries about the artificial intelligence business, with memory chip and other semiconductor names in Asia sliding too.
Why Is the Gap Between Spot and Contract Prices the Story?
Spot prices move first, but Micron's growth trajectory depends on contractually committed deliveries. The company's own guidance sets the yardstick: revenue of $61.5 billion for the first quarter of fiscal 2027, plus or minus $1.5 billion.
The recent track record explains why the market gives Micron credit. In the fourth quarter of fiscal 2026, revenue climbed 379% to $54.2 billion. Growth of that magnitude turns pricing sustainability into the central valuation question.
BofA attributes the NAND weakness to soft smartphone and PC demand plus additional supply. For Micron this is a warning flag, not proof of a downturn. The question is whether the softness stays confined to standard memory or spills into the stronger data center segment.
Is the Data Center Segment Immune?
There is a case for optimism in the divergence between memory segments. Soft demand for phones and PCs need not hit memory used in AI data centers. TrendForce, cited by the Seoul Economic Daily, expects contract prices for enterprise SSDs to rise 15–20% in the fourth quarter of 2026 versus the prior quarter. Not all memory products belong to the same cycle.
BofA is less patient on the rest of the market. It expects NAND for general IT use to fall another 5–10% sequentially in the first quarter of 2027, with the overall average NAND selling price also edging lower.
Is the Stock Cheap or a Value Trap?
Micron trades at 10 times adjusted earnings, while analysts expect annual growth in adjusted profit of 65% through fiscal 2028. That combination looks attractive if the estimates hold. The precondition is demanding: the expansion must materialize despite the first signs of market weakness.
The counterargument is older than the current cycle. Cheap valuations at the peak of a memory cycle can deceive, because a valuation case built on elevated earnings loses its force if prices and profits fall afterward. Morningorn expects the memory cycle to peak in early 2028. The pandemic downturn offers the cautionary precedent: Micron posted five consecutive quarters of declining revenue and losses. That is not a forecast, merely a reminder against extrapolating high growth indefinitely.
The key danger is not slower expansion but a reversal of prevailing price momentum. Weaker end markets and extra supply could weigh on pricing even if data center demand stays strong. The risk is more concrete than a vague worry about fading AI enthusiasm.
What Are the Next Catalysts?
Two dates matter. Nvidia reports quarterly results on November 17, offering clues on AI investment momentum. Micron follows on December 16. Nvidia's numbers are an industry signal, not a substitute for Micron's own performance.
The stronger test is whether Micron hits its revenue guidance and what management says about pricing ahead. As long as data center contract prices hold firm, the NAND spot weakness remains a contained problem. If it spreads to broader product groups, Micron's growth path deserves a more cautious assessment — and cycle risk moves to the foreground.
Source: newscase.com
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.
1,010 articles
Related articles
micron-shares-fall-even-as-analysts-call-chip-selloff-overblown-2f896707
Micron Shares Fall Even as Analysts Call Chip Selloff Overblown
sandisk-falls-6-6-to-826-66-as-memory-stocks-slide-before-nvidia
Sandisk Falls 6.6% to $826.66 as Memory Stocks Slide Before Nvidia
intel-s-120-billion-wipeout-drags-chip-stocks-into-broad-selloff
Intel's $120 Billion Wipeout Drags Chip Stocks Into Broad Selloff
micron-falls-20-in-a-month-as-ai-memory-trade-cools
Micron Falls 20% in a Month as AI Memory Trade Cools



