
Nvidia CEO exit exposes gaps in U.S. chip export controls
Malaysia, Singapore and Thailand received about $60 billion in AI chips over two years, exposing weak U.S. enforcement before new licensing rules tightened access.
- By
- Sophie Lindqvist
- Filed
- Channel
- Chips & Policy
- Read
- 5 min read
By Sophie Lindqvist
Malaysia, Singapore and Thailand received about $60 billion in AI chips over the past two years, CFR senior fellow Chris McGuire said, calling the flow “insane and way out of whack” for three small countries. The estimate frames the commercial risk behind a Commerce Department rule issued Monday.
McGuire called Monday’s Commerce rule the first major control strengthening since April 2025, but said important gaps remained.
What does the resignation change?
Rebecca Patterson said founder and CEO Jensen Huang resigned after relationships with three women surfaced. One woman allegedly supplied information to the Chinese government, while Huang’s conflict policy prohibited relationships with employees. These remain allegations.
Nvidia represented 1% of the S&P 500 three and a half years ago and 8.5% at end-October, Patterson said. Bloomberg put peak market value at $5.7 trillion in October; the selloff left $3.8 trillion. Trump later raised restoring Huang, while petition supporters called him vital. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent demanded an overhaul.
How much is the U.S. lead worth?
McGuire said Chinese AI models still train on America’s most advanced Blackwell processors. “Every single one is actually trained on U.S. chips,” he said. He cautioned that frontier lab capabilities remain private and model comparisons are increasingly unreliable.
McGuire estimated China produces 2% to 4% of U.S. AI computing power this year, leaving the United States with 25 to 50 times more compute. He put the model lead at six to 12 months, rising to 18 to 24 months if China used only domestic chips, with capability gaps widening from roughly 8-to-12 times to 50-to-100 times.
Fishman called hardware America’s clearest advantage; China leads on energy, while talent is roughly even.
What does the new rule close?
Late in the Biden administration, Commerce created licensing requirements for AI-chip shipments to Malaysia, Singapore and Thailand. Two days before implementation, the agency said it would not enforce the rule, opposed it and promised a replacement; the replacement languished for 18 months.
Nvidia opposed that anti-smuggling measure because it would restrict sales to Megaspeed and similar neoclouds. McGuire also alleged Commerce interference in Nvidia investigations, though the discussion offered no independent verification.
Monday’s rule reportedly came at Treasury and National Security Council direction. It addresses three areas:
- Licenses: Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia and Brazil.
- Remote access: restrictions on using chips bought elsewhere.
- Foundry rules: tighter controls on advanced fabrication at TSMC and Samsung.
The source did not establish that every domestic resale route was closed.
U.S. firms could sell advanced chips to Singaporean or Malaysian neoclouds, which could rent capacity to Chinese laboratories. Chinese laboratories could also rent access inside the United States, an arrangement McGuire called untenable.
Can enforcement change corporate behavior?
Fishman compared chip controls with financial sanctions. HSBC paid $2 billion in 2012, and BNP Paribas paid $9 billion in 2014, enough to erase more than one year of profit. Technology firms have faced no comparable penalty for chip-control violations.
Washington suspended an affiliates rule that would have extended restrictions to subsidiaries of listed firms. China answered with licensing for exports containing more than 0.1% Chinese rare earths, a measure Fishman said could affect $6.5 trillion in trade. The compromise came at Busan last October.
Trump and Xi were due to meet in China later this week; McGuire expected ceremony, not major concessions. China’s failure to deliver rare earths under the Busan agreement remained the larger dispute.
What does the scandal cost Nvidia?
Nvidia carries more than $100 billion in equity investments across over 100 companies and guarantees customer borrowing to buy its chips, Patterson said. That circular financing makes its health a concern for smaller chip buyers, cloud operators and the wider equity market.
Nvidia fell 5% Monday, while the S&P 500 remained almost 10% higher year to date. Patterson called the selloff a rotation toward stronger balance sheets, not an AI collapse.
Nvidia stopped disclosing Singapore revenue last year, which Patterson estimated had represented about 20% of sales. Culper Research separately estimated 20% of revenue had China exposure. McGuire said Nvidia had not lost a chip sale to controls; supply was redirected elsewhere.
Upcoming Nvidia earnings will test that defense. Huang and interim CEO Colette Kress were expected to face questions about internal and Justice Department investigations into what Nvidia knew about Megaspeed, which McGuire said remained unlisted. Anthropic’s planned IPO was described as targeting $1.3 trillion to $1.4 trillion.
What does the Iran war change?
Fishman said economic pressure alone would not secure Washington’s goals. A forecast put Iran’s GDP contraction this year at 7.5%, but Washington also seeks restored Strait of Hormuz access, missile-program limits and, in Fishman’s view, regime change. He said none appears within reach.
With Iran effectively selling no oil, the blockade has bite. Yet Brent crude remained near $95, roughly 20% above the start of the year, while Strait ship captains could earn $100,000 per month. Insurance and freight costs kept broader inflation risk elevated.
Fishman expects Gulf governments to seek bilateral protection arrangements with Iran, leaving the strait effectively controlled by Tehran.
McGuire said Iranian attacks damaged data centers in the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia. Removal of U.S. licensing requirements for UAE deployments left regulators without visibility, while continued conflict could redirect capital toward safer sites and compliant hyperscalers.
He also said China exports too few AI chips and has no AI data center outside China, leaving allies without a Chinese substitute for U.S. hardware.
What should investors watch?
Two tests will decide whether the rule changes the market: disclosed smuggling volumes and evidence that diverted chips reach fewer Chinese laboratories. The second test is pricing. If enforcement works, released capacity could ease U.S. compute shortages; if it fails, China’s access advantage will persist.
That trade-off will shape Nvidia’s regional revenue and the availability, rather than merely the location, of advanced AI capacity.
Source: cfr.org
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
News editor covering money, funding and market shifts around Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.
1,113 articles
Related articles
nvidia-supply-commitments-jump-to-279-billion-amid-governance-probe
Nvidia Supply Commitments Jump to $279 Billion Amid Governance Probe
jensen-huang-exit-threatens-3-2-billion-in-china-ai-projects
Jensen Huang exit threatens $3.2 billion in China AI projects
