Jensen Huang Just Resigned From Nvidia. A Study of 187 Forced CEO Exits Shows What Could Happen Next

Tech Business

Nvidia's Forced-CEO Reset: Study Flags 13-Point Market Lag

Nvidia's stock fell 13% in a week after Jensen Huang's exit. A 2021 study of 187 forced CEO departures found such stocks trail the market by 13 points over three years.

By
Grace Kim
Filed
Channel
Tech Business
Read
7 min read

Nvidia shares closed Friday, Nov. 13, at $162.85, 13% below the Nov. 6 close and 32% below the record $239.24 set Oct. 6. Jensen Huang resigned as president, chief executive and director on Thursday, Nov. 12; the stock fell 4.3% that day and the departure took effect immediately.

Colette Kress, Nvidia's chief financial officer since 2013, now serves as interim chief executive and keeps the CFO title. The board is searching inside and outside the company for a permanent successor. Harvey C. Jones, a former Synopsys chief executive, became the board's first-ever chair.

A 2021 study puts a measured number on the risk. It found that stocks which had beaten the market before a forced chief executive exit trailed the market by 13 percentage points over the next three years at the median.

What did the study of 187 forced exits find?

Paul Farah of Notre Dame University-Louaize and Hui Li of La Trobe University examined 735 chief executive changes at S&P 1500 companies from 2003 through 2012. They classified 187 as forced: the executive was ousted, resigned under pressure, or left young and fast with no comparable job waiting.

The two cohorts produced opposite outcomes, split by the stock's three-year record before the exit.

  • 125 laggards: the stock gained 1.0% in the five days around the announcement, and the median company beat the market by 18 points over the next three years.
  • 53 winners: the stock fell 3.4% in the five days around the news, and the median company trailed the market by 13 points over the next three years.

Removing a chief executive at a laggard was the safer trade; removing one at a winner carried a three-year penalty at the median. The limits constrain that reading. The winning group contains only 53 companies from 2003 to 2012, none of Nvidia's size. The study does not separate founders from hired managers. A median marks a tendency, not a forecast.

Why Nvidia sits on the wrong side of the sample

Nvidia's record puts it far on the outperforming side. From Nov. 13, 2023 to the final close before the resignation, the stock rose 258%. The S&P 500 rose 79%. The exit meets the study's definition of forced: The Wall Street Journal reported on Wednesday that the board was preparing to oust Huang, and he left the company and the board the next morning with no other job.

Two details also line up. Nvidia named no permanent successor, and 49% of the forced exits in the study had none either, which Farah and Li read as evidence that these departures are seldom planned. And the reason for the exit is public, through Huang's own Sunday statement and the reporting since, which described his admission of an affair with a woman that U.S. officials suspect of spying for China.

That second detail cuts the other way. In the study, when a board gave no clear reason for an exit, the stock fell 3.2% over five days; when the reason was known, the stock gained 1.5%. Nvidia had a public reason and the shares still fell on the resignation day, so the average does not settle the case.

The founder does not fit the sample. The average fired chief executive in the study was 54 and had held the job for six years. Huang is 63 and ran Nvidia for 33 years from its founding. Kress described the transition in company terms: "the extraordinary foundation Jensen created over the last 33 years."

How much shareholder value disappeared before the announcement?

PwC's Strategy& reviewed chief executive changes at the world's 2,500 largest public companies from 2011 to 2013. Forced exits cost shareholders mostly before the announcement, with a median 13% of total shareholder return in the year before the change and 0.6% in the year after.

Nvidia fits the first half. Over the past 12 months its stock is down 13%, while the S&P 500 is up 13%. Most of any remaining cost from the departure may therefore already sit in the price, which narrows what the study's three-year median can add.

What does the position look like for a concentrated holder?

One couple shows the concentration. The man is 68 and retired from an engineering job in 2021. In January 2016 he bought 200 Nvidia shares at $32.37, a $6,474 position in a taxable brokerage account, because he had used the company's chips at work.

Two splits later, four-for-one in 2021 and ten-for-one in 2024, he owns 8,000 shares. The couple's other $1.2 million sits in index funds in an IRA. The stake is worth about $1.3 million, 201 times the purchase price, and 52% of everything the couple owns outside the house.

Date Nvidia close Value of 8,000 shares
Oct. 6, record close $239.24 $1,913,920
Nov. 6, before the admission $186.64 $1,493,120
Nov. 11, before the resignation $173.73 $1,389,840
Nov. 12, close $166.19 $1,329,520
Nov. 13, close $162.85 $1,302,800

The position sits $611,120 below the October peak and $190,320 below Nov. 6, a week in which the S&P 500 rose 2.6%. The resignation day alone cost $60,320.

The study's five-day reaction of 3.4% would have cost $44,295 on this holding. Nvidia has lost four times that since the admission, because the decline came in stages across a week of reports before the board acted.

A 13-point median lag on $1,302,800 equals $169,364 less than the same money would earn in an index fund by late 2029. The industry-adjusted version, 15 points, reduces it by $195,420. Had Nvidia matched the laggard group and beaten the market by 18 points, the gap would run $234,504 the other way, and Nvidia's record does not support that case. These are medians: half the companies did better and half did worse, and the spread was wide.

What does the tax bill change?

The study does not tell this holder to sell. It sets a base case of the market's return minus something, over a wide range, for a stock that represents more than half of the couple's assets. Tax sets the price of each step. Selling all 8,000 shares at $162.85 would realize a $1,296,326 gain.

Stacked on $54,000 of Social Security and $48,000 of IRA withdrawals, and after the 2026 standard deduction, the first $40,500 of gain falls in the 0% capital gains bracket, the next $514,800 is taxed at 15%, and the remaining $741,026 at 20%. The 3.8% net investment income tax applies to most of it.

  • Sell all 8,000 shares: about $268,754 in federal tax and roughly $1,034,046 retained, with Medicare premiums two years from now set by this year's income.
  • Sell 2,000 shares: $324,082 realized gain, $48,921 in tax, about 15% of the gain, and $276,779 left for the index funds.
  • Sell 800 shares: $129,633 realized gain and $13,370 in tax, with no net investment income tax because income stays under $250,000.

A tenth a year over several years is the path most planners draw for a position this size. The alternative is time: shares held until death pass to heirs at that day's market value, and the whole gain goes untaxed, which is why a 68-year-old with a $6,474 basis is usually told to trim rather than sell.

What to watch on Nov. 17

Nvidia reports fiscal third-quarter results on Tuesday, Nov. 17, after the close, with Kress presenting as both chief executive and chief financial officer. The figures give investors the first operating readout under new leadership. The permanent chief executive is the other date to watch.

Farah and Li argue that boards which push out a winning chief executive often install a successor who cannot sustain the run. Whether Nvidia's board finds the exception is the whole bet for a holder who stays. On the median case, the market's first reaction to losing a winning chief executive is a 3.4% drop and three years of 13-point underperformance, and the Nov. 17 results plus the succession decision will set which path Nvidia takes.

Source: 247wallst.com

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.

991 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »