
Senate bill nears vote with $35 billion data-center grid cost
The Senate’s 73-25 cloture vote advances a grid-cost overhaul that Grid Strategies says could add $35 billion to data-center transmission charges over 10 years.
- By
- Tom Whitfield
- Filed
- Channel
- AI & Compute
- Read
- 5 min read
By Tom Whitfield
A 73-25 cloture vote on Nov. 9 put the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act on track for a final Senate vote this week. Grid Strategies estimates that its transmission rules could add $35 billion to data-center charges over 10 years; the bill would then face a House controlled by Democrats from January, where its path remains unclear.
S.5653, introduced Sept. 30 by the chairs and leading Democrats of the Senate's two energy committees, is a permitting overhaul. The sponsors were Republicans Shelley Moore Capito and Mike Lee and Democrats Sheldon Whitehouse and Martin Heinrich.
Majority Leader John Thune is pressing for passage. Whitehouse said: “The day of data center freeloading ends when this bill passes.”
What does Section 2107 change?
Section 2107, titled “Ratepayer Protection from Data Centers,” gives the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission 90 days to revise the transmission pricing policy that now lowers data-center connection charges. Its cost allocation would work as follows:
- New and existing data centers would pay their share of the existing transmission system plus a reasonable estimate of the added cost they cause.
- Centers accepting flexible or interruptible service would pay less.
- Other customers could not absorb new data centers' added costs. Centers leaving early would keep paying, and they would post financial guarantees before utilities built for them.
A manager's amendment extended these protections to centers of every size. The original text covered only facilities drawing at least 20 megawatts.
States would gain several options under the bill:
- Charge data centers more than cost and use the revenue to lower other customers' bills.
- Limit which data centers can connect.
- Require data centers to bring their own generation.
- Cap how much power a data center can draw.
The Energy Information Administration would track data-center electricity use. The Department of Energy would run a program giving local governments neutral information about proposed projects.
The pricing change would reverse a principle dating to 1994 that bars utilities from charging a customer twice for the same grid capacity. Texas presents a gap because ERCOT operates outside FERC's transmission authority, leaving the federal rules' application unclear.
Grid-connected data centers would cover a larger share of network and upgrade costs.
How large could the charge become?
Grid Strategies, a consulting firm, estimates annual data-center transmission charges would rise from about $2 billion to $5.5 billion. Its $35 billion 10-year increase forms part of a $55 billion total that combines $35 billion of existing-system costs with $20 billion of incremental costs.
PJM and MISO would account for about 82% of the annual charges. The model assumes 40.3 GW of new data-center capacity outside Texas.
If states fully use the bill's ratepayer-protection floor, Grid Strategies estimates states could recover about $136 billion in additional generation costs from data centers over 10 years. The firm presents that figure as exposure, not a forecast.
Heinrich initially attributed the $35 billion estimate to the Brattle Group, but Latitude Media corrected its report to credit Grid Strategies. Grid Strategies president Rob Gramlich does not expect most data centers to leave the grid, although on-site generation could supplement utility service and reduce transmission charges.
Rhodium Group projects household electricity bills would be $50 to $78 a year lower in 2040 under the bill.
The commercial effect depends on final implementation, especially whether states use the new pricing powers.
Who supports the bill, and who opposes it?
President Trump has endorsed the measure, saying it codifies the White House's ratepayer-protection pledge. The Edison Electric Institute, which represents investor-owned utilities, supports it after amendments changed the transmission provisions. Business groups and labor unions also back the bill.
The Data Center Coalition, whose members include Amazon, Google, Meta and Microsoft, has not endorsed the bill. Spokesman Jon Hukill said the group continues to evaluate its implications with members.
At the COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, Al Gore said on Monday that passage “would be a serious mistake, particularly in the wake of the astonishing election results last week.” He said it would “lock in a lot of new pipelines and fossil fuel facilities.”
Whitehouse said Gore had spoken with neither Heinrich nor him nor their teams before reaching that conclusion. Whitehouse is drafting amendments to close potential holes in the bill.
Earthjustice opposes the bill, though Abigail Dillen said it includes provisions that may compel data centers to cover the costs they impose on the grid. She cautioned that those protections depend on a new FERC policy and later state action, and argued that pipeline provisions could speed gas delivery to larger data-center complexes.
Aaron Weiss of the Center for Western Priorities warned that the bill could lock in a data-center binge on public lands. Tribal leaders and South Dakota's Public Utilities Commission also oppose the measure. Sen. Mike Rounds was the only Republican to vote against the cloture motion.
The political support is broad, but the bill still faces disputes over federal authority and state implementation.
What could data-center developers do?
The coalition says its members invest hundreds of billions of dollars a year in the United States. Section 2107 would reach new and existing grid-connected sites in FERC-regulated regions, rather than limiting the rule to centers with capacity of 20 megawatts or more.
Developers are already planning dozens of off-grid data centers powered by gas turbines or repurposed jet engines, The New York Times reported. Rhodium Group's Ben King said there is substantial uncertainty over whether the bill would change where data centers are built.
If the bill becomes law, higher grid charges could affect where some of the 40.3 GW of new capacity assumed outside Texas would be built. On-site generation offers an alternative to utility transmission, but Grid Strategies expects most data centers to remain on the grid, leaving the scale of any shift uncertain.
Source: mlq.ai
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.
1,002 articles
Related articles
senate-clears-73-25-hurdle-for-data-center-power-bill
Senate Clears 73-25 Hurdle for Data Center Power Bill
tva-books-1-7-billion-data-center-capacity-deal-at-1-5-million-per-mw
TVA Books $1.7 Billion Data Center Capacity Deal at $1.5 Million per MW
microsoft-tells-ai-builders-prove-data-centers-pay-off-for-locals
Microsoft Tells AI Builders: Prove Data Centers Pay Off for Locals
voters-restrict-data-centers-in-40-of-41-ballot-measures-as-ai-stocks-slide
Voters Restrict Data Centers in 40 of 41 Ballot Measures as AI Stocks Slide

