Do chip stocks bounce after a 10% fall? 52.4% vs 57.2%

Semiconductors

Chip Stocks After a 10% Monthly Fall: The Data Finds No Bounce

After a 10% monthly fall, the SOX chip index rose the next month 52.4% of the time versus 57.2% after ordinary months — a 389-month study finds no bounce rule.

By
Tom Whitfield
Filed
Channel
Semiconductors
Read
4 min read

The PHLX Semiconductor Index (SOX) closed October 2026 15.36% below its September close, and a study of every month since 1994 finds no evidence that chip stocks bounce after a fall of that size. After a monthly drop of 10% or more, the index rose the following month only 52.4% of the time — less often than the 57.2% rise rate recorded after all other months.

The analysis, published by TradingView contributor SignalPilotLabs, examined 389 monthly closes from June 1994 to October 2026. The index fell 10% or more in 43 of those months. For each case, the study checked whether the index stood higher one month later and three months later, compared with the outcomes after ordinary months. The author states the tests and thresholds were set in writing before the months were paired, a precaution against after-the-fact selection.

October's 15.36% decline followed an even sharper month: July 2026 brought a 20.61% fall. The July episode offers a live test case. The index rose 1.98% in August, but three months after July's crash it stood 5.50% lower.

What did the numbers show?

The core results cut against the popular bounce thesis:

  • One month later: higher in 22 of 42 cases (52.4%), versus 57.2% after non-crash months.
  • Three months later: higher in 23 of 42 cases (54.8%), versus 66.0% for other months.
  • Typical next-month move: +1.34% after a 10% month, versus +1.62% otherwise.
  • Typical three-month move: +1.21% after a crash month, versus +5.93% otherwise.

One case is excluded because its follow-on month remains open. The pattern is clear: if anything, the index rose slightly less often after a 10% fall than after an average month. There was no measurable bounce edge at either horizon.

Could the result be luck?

The study ran a randomization test, drawing 42 months at random 10,000 times. In 3,330 of those draws, the sample contained 22 rises or fewer over the next month — a common enough outcome that the observed figure fails a standard significance bar. At the three-month horizon, 1,010 of 10,000 draws showed 23 rises or fewer, which also falls short of the pre-set threshold.

The conclusion, in the author's words, is that there is "no rule either way." A 10% month in semiconductors has carried no reliable statistical signal about the direction of the next move.

Why do the two halves of the record disagree?

Splitting the data at 2010 reveals a sharp division. From 1994 to 2009, the index rose after only 11 of its 29 crash months, a 37.9% recovery rate, while other months of that era rose 53.2% of the time. The dot-com bust of 2000 to 2002 alone accounts for 12 of the 43 crash months, and 2008 adds another five. Falls in that era often kept falling.

Since 2010 the pattern reversed: the index rose after 11 of 13 crash months, or 84.6%, against 60.6% for ordinary months. The two halves point in opposite directions, and the study notes the historical record cannot say which half October 2026 belongs to.

How is the chart built?

The accompanying chart plots the SOX index monthly from January 2020 to October 2026 on a logarithmic scale, so equal percentage moves take equal vertical height. A short mark sits over each 10% month, and the following month is shaded — orange when the index rose, grey when it fell. October 2026 carries a blue mark because its outcome month is still open. A box plots one dot for every 10% month since 1994, with 22 of the 42 shaded orange. The author notes the chart starts in 2020 purely for readability, since candles across the full 1994-to-2026 span came out too thin; the underlying dataset covers the whole period. The last candle is November 2026, the month in progress.

What does the study not tell you?

The analysis covers monthly closes only, and past data at that. It does not explain why the index fell — each crash had its own story — and it says nothing about individual chip stocks or the size of the next move. The author frames the work as observations, not trading recommendations.

The practical takeaway is blunt: treat a bounce after a 10% chip month as about as likely as after any other month, and if October 2026 follows the post-2010 pattern rather than the pre-2010 one, investors will know only in hindsight.

Source: tradingview.com

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.

1,032 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »