
DRAM Price-Fixing Case Against Micron, Samsung, SK hynix Will Proceed
Judge Noël Wise has denied Micron, Samsung and SK hynix's motion to dismiss a DRAM price-fixing class action, citing new evidence of collusion after a 500% price surge.
- By
- Sophie Lindqvist
- Filed
- Channel
- Memory & Storage
- Read
- 3 min read
A US judge has denied Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix's motion to dismiss a proposed class-action DRAM price-fixing lawsuit that cites a 500% price surge within a single year. Judge Noël Wise ruled the case is plausible enough to proceed to trial, and the three memory makers must respond to the complaint by December 7, with a case management conference set for January 2027.
The ruling is not a verdict. Judge Wise herself stressed that this does not mean the defendants are guilty. Both sides must still present evidence and arguments before the court reaches any decision.
Why did the judge reject the dismissal?
The defendants argued the suit was merely a rerun of the antitrust case filed against the DRAM industry in 2018. Judge Wise rejected that framing. She found the plaintiffs have established new evidence suggesting collusion among the big three memory manufacturers.
The chipmakers contended they watch each other like hawks because competition is so tight. Judge Wise disagreed, and her written decision contains the line now anchoring the case: "Their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation — an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do."
That single sentence reframes the dispute. The question is no longer whether the companies observed each other, but whether they acted in concert.
What do the plaintiffs allege happened?
The plaintiffs — 17 individuals and small businesses — allege the companies made four parallel moves that restricted DRAM supply and produced the current shortage, during which prices jumped by as much as 500% in one year. Their cited evidence includes:
- Simultaneous DRAM production cuts from October 2022 to April 2023.
- A coordinated pivot to HBM immediately after those cuts.
- Announcements winding down DDR4 production within a span of three months.
- A failure to expand production capacity "despite these extraordinary prices — the single most powerful supply signal the DRAM industry has ever produced," in the plaintiffs' words.
The plaintiffs also point to additional conduct they say supports the pattern: stringent customer vetting procedures introduced during the shortage, refusals to sign long-term contracts with DRAM customers, Micron's decision to shut down Crucial, its consumer memory brand, and multiple public statements projecting the shortage. They further cite the companies' involvement in previous price-fixing scandals.
How did the defendants answer?
Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix called each of these moves a logical business decision designed to maximize revenue during a period of great demand. They said the conduct was "consistent with [their own] independent self-interest."
They also offered a structural defense. The DRAM market is highly concentrated, so all three companies are "reacting to the same market pressures," and a similar response should be expected. Parallel behavior, in their telling, reflects market structure rather than coordination.
The judge was not persuaded at this stage. She found the plaintiffs' theory plausible enough that the case should move forward — a low bar, but one that keeps the three companies in litigation they had tried to end early.
What happens next?
The procedural calendar is now set. The defendants have until December 7 to respond to the original complaint. The case management conference, which will determine administrative matters, is scheduled for January 2027.
Discovery will test the plaintiffs' inference of coordination against the defendants' market-structure explanation, and a judgment remains years away. For DRAM buyers who absorbed the 500% price spike, the case keeps alive the possibility of compensation — but the court has so far confirmed only plausibility, not collusion.
Source: Tom's Hardware
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
News editor covering money, funding and market shifts around Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.
1,002 articles
Related articles
judge-lets-dram-price-fixing-class-action-against-samsung-sk-hynix-and-micron-pr
Judge Lets DRAM Price-Fixing Class Action Against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron Proceed
five-year-sentence-in-samsung-leak-case-marks-new-phase-of-chip-talent-war
Five-Year Sentence in Samsung Leak Case Marks New Phase of Chip Talent War
arm-and-amd-drop-5-as-qualcomm-verdict-fuels-chip-selloff-610c8b75
Arm and AMD Drop 5% as Qualcomm Verdict Fuels Chip Selloff


