Judge lets a DRAM supply-conspiracy class action against Samsung, Micron and SK hynix proceed

Memory & Storage

Judge Lets DRAM Price-Fixing Class Action Against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron Proceed

Judge Noël Wise refused to dismiss a class action alleging Samsung, SK hynix and Micron restricted conventional DRAM supply, citing a 697% price rise over 18 months.

By
Rebecca Stone
Filed
Channel
Memory & Storage
Read
3 min read

A federal judge has refused to dismiss a proposed class action that accuses Samsung, SK hynix and Micron of conspiring to restrict conventional DRAM supply — a market where the three held more than 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025 and where prices climbed 697% in 18 months.

U.S. District Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California denied the companies' joint motion to dismiss on Nov. 14, 2026, in Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics (No. 5:26-cv-06345). It's a pleading-stage decision. Not a finding of liability. The defendants must answer the complaint by Dec. 7, and the first case management conference is scheduled for Jan. 12, 2027.

The 17 named plaintiffs — consumers and small businesses from five states — allege that since October 2022 the three memory makers have "maintained a continuing agreement, combination, or conspiracy" in the conventional DRAM market, violating Section 1 of the Sherman Act, with additional claims under California, Florida, Minnesota, New York and Wisconsin law. The complaint, filed June 25, argues that conventional DRAM prices rose 697% over 18 months while none of the three meaningfully expanded output.

What did the court actually accept?

The defendants pushed back hard. Each company acted in its own interest, they argued, and the case merely reruns DRAM II — the suit over a 2016-to-2018 supply restriction that the Ninth Circuit dismissed in 2022. "The Court finds that it is not," Wise wrote.

Her order leans on a pattern of timing and conduct:

  • Staggered production cuts: SK hynix cut output on Oct. 26, 2022; Micron followed three weeks later; Samsung joined in April 2023 — after saying there would be no "artificial production cut."
  • A coordinated DDR4 exit: On this point, the defendants "offer no rationale for their sudden, rapid, and coordinated exit," the judge wrote.
  • AI supply lock-ups: long-term supply agreements with AI customers, while conventional buyers were refused long-term contracts.
  • Micron's Crucial closure: the Dec. 3, 2025 decision to shut down its consumer brand.
  • Matching customer vetting: near-identical vetting procedures the three introduced in January 2026.

Taken together, these moves are "the sort that at the pleading stage, it appears no reasonable firm would make without a prior agreement," Wise wrote.

What did she throw out?

Plenty. The DDR3 allegations failed because Micron kept producing DDR3. Public statements to investors got no weight. Neither did meetings at industry conferences. And she agreed that a bare pivot to high-bandwidth memory plus a decision to restrict supply isn't enough on its own.

The ruling's most quotable line answers the defendants' citation of Judge Richard Posner, who observed that competitors in concentrated markets "watch each other like hawks." The plaintiffs' contentions, Wise wrote, "are more akin to hawks flying in formation, an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do."

Why the history matters

The order notes that Samsung and SK hynix paid fines over the 1998-to-2002 DRAM price-fixing cartel — the episode in which Micron received immunity as a cooperating whistleblower. None of the three companies had commented publicly on the ruling, Hardware Busters reported. Separately, MLQ.ai has covered the outsized profits the memory shortage has delivered, reporting that memory makers are earning 80% margins as the AI crunch reaches Apple, PCs and Nvidia's supply chain.

The case now moves to discovery, where the coordination allegations — the DDR4 exit, the AI lock-ups, the matched vetting — will face their first real test against internal documents.

Source: mlq.ai

Share this article:

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

Correspondent covering technology and product news in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.

985 articles

Related articles

« Previous article