Epic says Apple is withholding 122,000 documents on its proposed App Store link-out fee and asks for daily fines

Tech Business

Epic Seeks 122,000 Apple Documents Over Link-Out Fee

Epic says Apple withheld more than 122,000 documents matching agreed search terms and seeks daily sanctions after Dec. 2, 2026, amid a fight over a proposed 5%-15% App Store link-out commission.

By
Rebecca Stone
Filed
Channel
Tech Business
Read
3 min read

By Rebecca Stone

Epic says Apple is withholding more than 122,000 internal documents and asks a federal judge to impose daily monetary sanctions after Dec. 2, 2026.

The Nov. 13 motion, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, targets the discovery process behind Apple’s proposed commission on purchases made through links that leave the App Store.

Which documents does Epic say Apple withheld?

Epic says agreed search terms ran across the files of seven Apple executives. Four, identified as decision-makers on the fee, were Tim Cook, Eddy Cue, Carson Oliver and Chief Financial Officer Kevan Parekh. The other three were Nate Barton, Alex Roman and Phil Schiller.

Apple produced 632 documents from those seven custodians, including 157 from the four fee decision-makers, according to Epic. The company withheld more than 122,000 documents that it considers irrelevant or nonresponsive.

Epic says the withheld material represents roughly 99.14% of the documents directly hit by the search terms. The terms included case-related words such as “proffer,” “contempt,” “injunction” and “link-out.”

During meet-and-confer discussions, Apple told Epic that the searches mostly returned press releases, analyst reports and other irrelevant material. According to Epic, Apple maintains that its relevance review was proper.

Epic also says earlier contempt proceedings produced nearly 27,000 documents from the same custodians or their predecessors. That earlier production makes the current 632-document response a focal point of the dispute.

According to Epic, Apple’s production contains no App Store profit-and-loss statements, no internal analysis of the proposed commissions’ financial impact, and no data supporting Apple’s statement that its incremental link-out costs are “essentially zero.”

What remedy does Epic want?

Epic asks the court to order Apple to produce every non-privileged document matching the agreed terms by Dec. 2, 2026, irrespective of Apple’s relevance or responsiveness assessment. Apple would retain the right to withhold privileged material.

That deadline falls one week after Apple’s Nov. 25 deadline to substantially complete its document production. Epic wants to review the broader set itself.

The motion also requests “a daily monetary sanction for each day Apple fails to comply after December 2, 2026,” although Epic does not propose a dollar amount.

Epic’s filing cites the earlier contempt proceeding, in which the court found Apple’s privilege over-designation intentional and sanctioned it. Epic argues that the earlier finding means Apple cannot be trusted to correct the problem through its own re-review.

How did the commission dispute reach the court?

Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers ruled in 2021 that Apple’s anti-steering rules violated California’s Unfair Competition Law. The ruling barred Apple from preventing developers from linking customers to outside purchase options.

In 2025, Gonzalez Rogers held Apple in civil contempt and barred any commission on linked-out purchases. The Ninth Circuit upheld the contempt finding but sent the question of what commission, if any, Apple may charge back to the district court.

Apple filed proposed rates on Aug. 13, 2026. According to 9to5Mac, the proposal ranges from 5% to 15% on purchases made through external links.

Epic has separately asked the U.S. Supreme Court to uphold the contempt ruling.

What happens next?

A hearing on Epic’s motion had been scheduled for Nov. 24 before Gonzalez Rogers. 9to5Mac reported that a new order, which was not yet public, refers the discovery dispute to a magistrate judge and terminates the related deadlines and hearings.

Neither the Epic filing nor the 9to5Mac report included Apple’s response. The central commercial question remains what commission, if any, the court permits on linked-out purchases, and the requested financial records could inform that decision before Apple’s proposed 5% to 15% rates take effect.

Source: mlq.ai

Share this article:

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

Correspondent covering technology and product news in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.

1,092 articles

Related articles

« Previous article