
Huawei Racketeering Trial Goes to Jury in Brooklyn After Two-Day Close
A Brooklyn jury deliberates after a two-month trial on racketeering, bank fraud and Iran sanctions charges against Huawei and three subsidiaries, with Meng Wanzhou's 2021 deal at the center.
- By
- Nathan Brooks
- Filed
- Channel
- Chips & Policy
- Read
- 3 min read
A Brooklyn jury begins deliberating this week in United States v. Huawei, the criminal case charging the Chinese telecommunications company and three subsidiaries with a 20-year racketeering scheme, bank fraud and Iran sanctions violations. Judge Ann Donnelly of the Eastern District of New York was expected to instruct the jury Wednesday, with deliberations to follow, Courthouse News reported. Reuters said deliberations were likely to begin the same day.
Closing arguments ended Tuesday, more than two months into a trial that began in September. The docket is 1:18-cr-00457. Prosecutors called more than 60 witnesses; the defense called roughly 15, according to Reuters.
What does the jury have to decide?
Huawei and its subsidiaries face counts of racketeering conspiracy, conspiracy to steal trade secrets, wire and bank fraud, conspiracy to defraud the United States, violations of the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, and conspiracies to launder money and obstruct justice.
The Justice Department accuses the company of encouraging employees to take proprietary technology from US competitors and of lying to HSBC and other banks about its business in Iran, a sanctioned country. Huawei has pleaded not guilty and argues the government failed to prove its charges.
Jurors saw evidence involving T-Mobile, Cisco Systems and Quintel. One exhibit was a video of a Huawei employee, inside T-Mobile's secure lab, breaking a piece off the carrier's phone-testing robot, "Tappy," and putting it in his backpack. Prosecutors also alleged Huawei employees took Cisco router technology and used it in routers Huawei sold in the United States.
What did prosecutors argue?
Assistant US Attorney Meredith Arfa delivered a closing argument on Monday that ran about five hours. She told jurors Huawei built its business on "theft, lies and cover-ups" and signaled to employees: "You can lie and steal and cheat as long as you're doing it for the benefit of Huawei."
Prosecutors accused founder Ren Zhengfei of brushing off concerns about intellectual-property theft. They said company officials offered bonuses to employees who passed along competitors' confidential information.
On the bank-fraud counts, the government contends Huawei hid the nature of its Iran business from HSBC and other banks. It described its subsidiary Skycom as a business partner and claimed only limited operations in Iran, prosecutors said.
Central to that charge is the 2021 deferred prosecution agreement signed by chief financial officer Meng Wanzhou, Ren's daughter, after her 2018 arrest in Vancouver. In it, she admitted misleading HSBC executives about the company's Iran dealings.
"Meng admitted that she, meaning Huawei, [repeatedly] lied to HSBC," Arfa said. "This is indisputable evidence of a conspiracy to defraud Huawei's banks, carried out by one of Huawei's most senior executives."
What did Huawei argue?
Defense lawyer Brian Heberlig of Steptoe told jurors the government "didn't start with the evidence and ask where it led. They decided it was a criminal enterprise and tried to make everything fit." Prosecutors, he said, "began with guilt and worked backwards" and "cherry-picked" trade-secret incidents.
Huawei does not dispute the T-Mobile and Cisco episodes. It says it responded to them: the Tappy employee was fired, and the company recalled the routers and offered to replace them with Cisco routers free of charge. "Can any compliance program guarantee perfection? Of course not," Heberlig said.
On the bank counts, he argued the banks knew about Huawei's work in Iran and its relationship with Skycom, and accepted the risk because Iran was a small part of their business. He asked jurors to read Meng's agreement closely: she learned during the government's investigation that her statements to HSBC were misrepresentations but did not know it at the time. "The agreement is no shortcut to a guilty verdict," he said.
The verdict will shape how much leverage Washington retains over one of China's flagship technology firms, and whether a deferred prosecution agreement signed four years ago in Vancouver can carry the weight of a criminal conviction in Brooklyn.
Source: mlq.ai
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.
1,059 articles
Related articles
california-tech-ceo-arrested-over-alleged-300m-china-ties-3e538e41
California Tech CEO Arrested Over Alleged $300M China Ties
five-year-sentence-in-samsung-leak-case-marks-new-phase-of-chip-talent-war
Five-Year Sentence in Samsung Leak Case Marks New Phase of Chip Talent War
huawei-s-chip-advance-fuels-debate-over-us-export-controls-1cbd4a9b
Huawei's Chip Advance Fuels Debate Over US Export Controls
huawei-to-launch-new-osta-phone-brand-six-years-after-honor-sale
Huawei to Launch New Osta Phone Brand on Nov. 20, Six Years After Honor Sale



