Science & TechnologyLOT 261119 · 3 min read

LiberNT Beats Windows 11 in 112 of 132 System Tests, Developers Claim

LiberNT, a GPL3.0 Windows 11 alternative forked from ReactOS and largely vibe coded, claims wins in 112 of 132 benchmark tests against Microsoft's OS on an M3 Pro Mac.

By Tom Whitfield541 words

Key takeaways

  1. LiberNT claims to beat Windows 11 in 112 of 132 system tests, with wins exceeding 2000 percent in some cases and a worst-case 28 percent deficit
  2. The benchmarks ran on an Apple Mac with an M3 Pro chip, covering file caching, memory handling, threads and locks, and FAT32/NTFS storage
  3. LiberNT started as a ReactOS fork and has replaced its boot loader, graphics stack, memory manager and, as of Wednesday, its kernel
  4. The OS targets amd64, arm64 and riscv64 platforms and is licensed under GPL3.0
  5. Developers say AI writes and reviews code, with humans validating all end-to-end tests before anything merges
Developer vibe codes Windows 11 alternative operating system for amd64, arm64, and riscv64 hardware
Developer vibe codes Windows 11 alternative operating system for amd64, arm64, and riscv64 hardware — Pexels / pixabay

A free, 64-bit Windows alternative called LiberNT has been benchmarked by its developers against Microsoft's Windows 11, and the team claims it wins 112 of 132 system tests. The remaining comparison points went to Windows, with LiberNT's worst result showing a 28 percent performance deficit, while its best results allegedly exceed Windows 11 by more than 2000 percent.

The benchmarks ran on unusual hardware: an Apple Mac powered by an M3 Pro chip, hosting both operating systems. The test suite covered file caching, memory handling, threads and locks, and storage on both FAT32 and NTFS file systems. These are developer-published figures, not independently verified results, so the numbers describe the project's own claims rather than confirmed third-party measurements.

What is LiberNT?

The name signals the project's intent: Liber for free, NT for the New Technology architecture that underpins Microsoft's Windows. Released under the GNU GPL3.0 license, LiberNT aims to run applications written for Windows 11 while remaining entirely free. The developers describe the project as "built out of love for the NT architecture."

The operating system began as a fork of ReactOS, the long-running open-source effort to recreate Windows compatibility. It has since diverged considerably. The project has replaced the boot loader, the graphics stack and the memory manager, and on Wednesday it shipped a new kernel. The team is explicit about boundaries: "LiberNT is not affiliated with or endorsed by the ReactOS project or Microsoft."

LiberNT targets modern 64-bit hardware across three architectures: amd64, arm64 and riscv64. The stated goal is a free Windows alternative that is, in the developers' words, "stable, reliable and efficient."

How much of it did AI write?

The developers are unusually direct that the operating system was largely vibe coded, meaning generated with AI assistance. The project's GitHub page states the workflow plainly.

"AI is part of how LiberNT is built. It helps us review and write code, and everything it writes is then reviewed by a human," the page explains. "Before anything reaches the main branch, a person runs and validates the end-to-end tests. We care about this project too much to let a regression slip through."

In other words, a human gate stands between machine-written code and the shipping product. Every change must pass end-to-end validation before it merges.

Can you actually run it?

Yes, in a limited sense. The full source code is available on GitHub, and the project publishes ready-made builds as bootable disk images. That puts LiberNT ahead of many announced-but-vaporware operating system projects, though a bootable image is a long way from daily-driver reliability.

The practical question for any Windows alternative is whether ordinary productivity applications survive the transition. Firefox, Microsoft Word and older Photoshop releases are exactly the kind of software a would-be user would test first, and no independent reports yet confirm they run without stability problems.

A free kernel claiming wins over Windows in the large majority of system tests is a bold data point, but it remains a self-reported one. The next test that matters belongs to end users booting the disk images and running their own applications on real workloads.

Tom's Hardware (Source)

Filed under

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.

1,122 articles

Read also

« Previous article