Thanks To Jensen's Resignation, Nvidia Is Now Cheaper Than A Troubled Italian Bank

Tech Business

Nvidia Trades at 12x Earnings After Huang Exit and Chip Selloff

Nvidia has fallen 32% from its record and trades near 12x forward earnings, its cheapest since 2012, after Jensen Huang's resignation triggered a chip selloff.

By
Grace Kim
Filed
Channel
Tech Business
Read
3 min read

Nvidia shares have fallen roughly 32% from their record high and now trade at about 12 times next-twelve-months earnings, the lowest multiple since 2012. The trigger was a broad chip selloff combined with the resignation of CEO Jensen Huang. A Seeking Alpha analyst who published the assessment rates the stock BUY with a twelve-month base case of about $227.

The valuation comparison is stark. On fiscal 2027 earnings estimates, Nvidia is now cheaper than Monte dei Paschi di Siena, the Italian bank the state rescued in 2017, according to the analyst. Nvidia's earnings per share are expected to grow three times as fast as the bank's over that horizon.

Why does the moat survive the CEO's exit?

The analyst argues Nvidia's competitive position rests on four supports that do not depend on who runs the company:

  • CUDA, the software ecosystem that locks developers into Nvidia hardware
  • The product roadmap
  • Supply commitments secured for future output
  • Customers who have already financed their purchases

The analyst wrote: "Nvidia's moat rests on CUDA, its roadmap, its supply commitments, and customers who have already financed their purchases, and none of these depend on who is the CEO."

That framing treats the leadership change as a sentiment shock rather than a structural break. The company retains the same silicon franchise, the same software lock-in, and the same customer base that pre-paid for capacity.

Is the market pricing a fundamentals change?

The evidence says no. Consensus EPS estimates for the next fiscal year have barely moved since the selloff began, the analyst notes. The stock is being repriced while the earnings base stays roughly intact.

The analyst draws a direct parallel to March, when markets were rattled by the war in Iran. Then, as now, the share price absorbed the shock while estimates held firm. Noise, in the analyst's view, is being mistaken for deterioration in the business.

Three weeks before the current decline, the same analyst had published an outlook piece arguing Nvidia no longer represented the best bet in its industry and that a broader, index-based semiconductor exposure was preferable. That piece predates Huang's resignation. The new article marks a return to a direct Nvidia position on valuation grounds.

What are the risks?

The analyst names three. First, Intel after 2018, a reference to the precedent of a dominant chipmaker losing its edge after a strategic misstep. Second, export controls, which can cut Nvidia off from China-bound revenue at regulatory discretion. Third, exposure to neoclouds, the startup GPU cloud operators whose spending is less proven than that of the largest hyperscalers.

Each risk targets a different pillar. Export controls threaten demand. Neocloud exposure threatens the quality of the customer-financed purchasing that underpins the moat. The Intel precedent is the tail risk that a technology franchise can erode faster than the balance sheet suggests.

The analyst holds a beneficial long position in NVDA, SOXX, VOO, TQQQ, and QQQ through stock ownership, options, or other derivatives, and states the article expresses personal opinions without third-party compensation.

The setup now mirrors a familiar pattern in semiconductor equities: a leadership shock and a sector-wide selloff have compressed the multiple to a twelve-year low while earnings estimates stand still, and the analyst's $227 base case implies the gap between price and fundamentals closes as the CUDA ecosystem and pre-financed customer demand carry the company through the transition.

Source: seekingalpha.com

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.

991 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »