
Rare-earth stocks fall as feedstock concerns hit USA Rare Earth
USA Rare Earth fell 7% after a William Blair downgrade, while Serra Verde's 325-tonne fourth-quarter guide, federal support and Trump-Xi talks shape investor risk.
- By
- Tom Whitfield
- Filed
- Channel
- Tech Business
- Read
- 4 min read
By Tom Whitfield
USA Rare Earth (NASDAQ: USAR) shares fell 7% to $6.65 in morning trading, extending the stock’s decline to 37% over the past month. Critical Metals (NASDAQ: CRML) dropped 5% to $3.97, while MP Materials (NYSE: MP) fell 3% to $35.07 and United States Antimony (NYSE: UAMY) also traded lower. The S&P 500 was down 1% and the materials sector 0.2%, leaving the rare-earth group under greater pressure than the broader market.
Why did USA Rare Earth sell off?
William Blair downgraded USA Rare Earth on November 16 over feedstock issues, and the downgrade helped pull down the wider group. The selloff came ahead of a meeting between U.S. President Donald Trump and Chinese leader Xi Jinping. Much of the investment case for U.S. rare-earth producers rests on reducing reliance on China, which makes trade relations a direct commercial variable. The downgrade therefore shifted attention from long-term policy support to near-term feedstock and operating risks.
What do the operating figures show?
On November 9, USA Rare Earth reported Q3 2026 revenue of $3 million, well below the $13.55 million estimate. The company closed its Serra Verde combination on September 3, so the Brazilian asset contributed almost nothing to the quarter. A $136.57 million gain on the fair value of financial instruments lifted generally accepted accounting principles net income to $11.71 million. The adjusted loss still reached minus $0.44 per share, and the company reported $143.69 million of cash used in operations during the quarter.
USA Rare Earth said recent non-China dysprosium oxide prices ran 14 to 16 times prices in China. Serra Verde sells its output under a 15-year take-or-pay contract priced on non-China prices, linking its sales to that premium. Reported profit and contracted pricing therefore tell different stories: valuation gains produced earnings, while future sales depend on a large non-China price gap.
How do the peer companies compare?
Critical Metals traded at $3.97, down 5%. The pre-revenue developer has disclosed substantial doubt about its ability to continue as a going concern, and its current plan calls for mining at the Tanbreez rare-earth project in Greenland to begin by the end of 2028.
MP Materials traded at $35.07, down 3%, the steadiest showing in the group, and remained down 31% year to date. Its neodymium-praseodymium production rose 41% year over year to 1,018 metric tons in Q3 2026. The company also completed magnet qualification with a major automaker and expects commercial deliveries to begin in Q4 2026.
United States Antimony also traded lower. The antimony producer supplies military-specification ingots to the Defense Logistics Agency under a sole-source contract. The peer comparison favors operating evidence: MP reports current production and magnet deliveries, while Critical Metals remains a pre-revenue financing risk.
How do their supply chains differ?
USA Rare Earth is building a mine-to-magnet supply chain across the United States, Brazil and the United Kingdom. It includes Serra Verde’s Brazilian mine, metal and alloy plants operated by the Less Common Metals unit, and a magnet plant in Stillwater, Oklahoma. Recent acquisitions brought several components into the company, leaving it to absorb integration costs while output ramps up. Chief executive Thras Moraitis said: “Demand for a secure and responsible supply of rare earth products is becoming increasingly acute across a broad range of technology-driven sectors.” The corporate structure gives USA Rare Earth access across the full chain, but recent acquisitions leave execution and integration exposed.
MP Materials runs one main mine and processing site at Mountain Pass in California and is building magnet capacity in Texas. Its Department of War partnership includes price protection that helps shield it from rare-earth price swings. Critical Metals sits earlier in development, with a Greenland rare-earth deposit and an Austrian lithium project that both still require financing. MP has the operating base and near-term magnet deliveries; USA Rare Earth offers broader integration, while Critical Metals still depends on project finance.
What could the Trump-Xi meeting change?
One explanation for the stock trimming is that investors fear a U.S.-China agreement could ease supply tensions and weaken the case for non-China supply. Federal backing includes a $750 million Department of War investment in USA Rare Earth’s contract vehicle and a government forward purchase of at least $300 million of product. Critics point to the $143.69 million in operating cash use during Q3 and to the risk that better relations would shrink non-China price premiums. Government support provides capital and demand, while the commercial premium remains exposed to the policy outcome of the talks.
Serra Verde now faces its own near-term test: the company’s Q4 sales guidance calls for at least 325 tonnes of total rare-earth oxide. MP Materials expects commercial magnet deliveries to begin in Q4 2026, while Critical Metals plans Tanbreez mining by the end of 2028. Sentiment across the group could remain fragile until the Trump-Xi meeting produces a clearer outcome. The next measurable test is Serra Verde’s fourth-quarter oxide volume, while any post-meeting easing in U.S.-China tensions could narrow the non-China price premium supporting USA Rare Earth’s sales.
Source: 247wallst.com
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.
1,054 articles
Related articles
usa-rare-earth-rebounds-11-after-3-million-quarter-exposed-supply-squeeze
USA Rare Earth Rebounds 11% After $3 Million Quarter Exposed Supply Squeeze
us-chip-supply-chain-still-runs-through-china-for-rare-earths-3aff46ea
US Chip Supply Chain Still Runs Through China for Rare Earths
usa-rare-earth-q3-revenue-hits-3m-stock-drops-11-after-miss
USA Rare Earth Q3 revenue hits $3M, stock drops 11% after miss
yttrium-costs-125-times-more-in-europe-than-china-as-export-curbs-bite
Yttrium Costs 125 Times More in Europe Than China as Export Curbs Bite


