EU says Temu fails to stop illegal products, opening the door to a fine of up to 6% of PDD's global revenue

Tech Business

Temu’s EU breach could trigger a 6% worldwide-turnover fine

The EU says Temu failed to curb illegal-product listings. A final decision could impose a fine of up to 6% of worldwide turnover and require fixes under the DSA.

By
Nathan Brooks
Filed
Channel
Tech Business
Read
4 min read

A confirmed European Commission finding could fine PDD Holdings-owned Temu up to 6% of total worldwide annual turnover.

On Nov. 17, the Commission preliminarily concluded that Temu breached the EU’s Digital Services Act by failing to take reasonable, proportionate and effective steps to stop illegal products from being sold on its marketplace. No final decision or current fine amount has been set.

“Shopping online should not mean risking the purchase of illegal and unsafe products,” said Henna Virkkunen, the Commission’s executive vice-president for tech sovereignty. The finding targets marketplace controls, and Temu can respond in writing before the Commission makes a final decision.

What did the Commission find?

The Commission identified three weaknesses in Temu’s controls. The preliminary decision does not yet set a final remedy.

  • Product checks. Temu asks sellers for test reports on only a very small share of products and often does not check the reports it receives. It labels toys, electronics and cosmetics as high risk, yet does not prioritize them in physical checks and has not increased inspections as listings grew.
  • Moderation. Temu’s system mainly examines listing information and the marketplace’s own terms rather than whether a product is safe. Its number of human moderators has not kept pace with listings.
  • Seller sanctions. Penalties hit individual stores rather than the trader operating them. A trader whose store closes can keep selling through other stores, and traders can commit numerous serious violations, including sales of products that fail safety checks, before any store is suspended.

The Commission said product checks, content moderation and seller sanctions were all ineffective. Those conclusions remain preliminary.

In practice, the store-level penalty resembles changing the locks on one shop while leaving the trader free to trade elsewhere. That matters because Temu’s marketplace can preserve access for a seller the Commission says has committed serious violations.

How does this fit Temu’s other EU case?

The new findings fall under Article 35 of the DSA, which requires very large platforms to take concrete steps to reduce the risks they identify. Temu remains subject to a fine if the Commission confirms its preliminary view.

This is Temu’s second DSA case this year. In May, the Commission found Temu in breach of a separate duty to carry out a proper risk assessment and fined it €200 million. In October, the Commission approved Temu’s action plan to fix that breach.

The €200 million penalty is a confirmed amount and illustrates the range used so far. It does not set the value of the new case, whose maximum is a legal ceiling rather than an analyst estimate.

Temu’s formal proceedings began in October 2024 and covered illegal products, potentially addictive design, recommendation systems and data access for researchers. The Nov. 17 findings address only illegal products, leaving the other proceeding subjects outside this decision.

What happens next?

Temu may examine the Commission’s investigation file and submit a written response. The European Board for Digital Services will be consulted, and the Commission’s release did not set a deadline for a final decision.

If the Commission confirms its view, it can adopt a non-compliance decision, impose a fine of up to 6% of total worldwide annual turnover and order Temu to remedy the breach. For PDD Holdings, which is listed in the United States, a fine at the 6% ceiling would be calculated on worldwide turnover rather than only European sales.

The distinction is commercially material. A European-only revenue base would narrow the exposure; a global base does not. The 6% figure remains a conditional maximum, not a booked charge or announced settlement.

What must Temu change?

A final remedy order would require stronger action across the three areas cited by the Commission. Temu would need to improve product verification, give safety greater weight in moderation, and apply sanctions to traders rather than only their individual stores.

No deadline, fine amount or detailed remedy package for this case has yet been published. The immediate commercial question is therefore not whether Temu can appeal, but how extensively it must change its marketplace controls.

If the Commission confirms its view, PDD faces a potential global-revenue penalty while Temu must tighten seller controls, leaving compliance and seller enforcement as the immediate commercial issues.

Source: mlq.ai

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.

1,056 articles

Related articles

« Previous article