Chips & PolicyLOT 261119 · 3 min read

TSMC and Samsung Suspend Advanced Chip Orders From Chinese Designers

TSMC halted 16nm-and-below orders from Chinese designers without US licenses as a Nov. 19 rule removed two of three ways foundries could clear advanced chips for export.

By Tom Whitfield662 words

Key takeaways

  1. TSMC halted Chinese designers' orders on 16nm and below unless they hold US export licenses, Reuters reported Nov. 19.
  2. The Commerce Department rule effective Nov. 19 removes two of three pathways foundries had to clear advanced-node chips for restricted destinations.
  3. Affected Chinese designers are generally limited to 28nm and 40nm without high-bandwidth memory or advanced packaging.
  4. Transistor-count attestation thresholds are 30 billion now, 35 billion in 2027 and 40 billion from 2029 for chips without HBM.
  5. Banks paused a $480 million chip loan tied to ByteDance, Bloomberg reported.
TSMC and Samsung curb some chip shipments to Chinese customers as a new US rule takes effect, reports say
TSMC and Samsung curb some chip shipments to Chinese customers as a new US rule takes effect, reports say — ValdasMiskinis / pixabay

TSMC has halted chip orders from Chinese designers on 16-nanometer processes and below unless the customers hold US export licenses, Reuters reported on Nov. 19, citing two people familiar with the matter. The Financial Times reported the same day that TSMC and Samsung have suspended some chip shipments to Chinese customers until they secure new licenses from the Commerce Department. Both moves coincide with an interim final rule that took effect immediately on Nov. 19.

The restrictions bite hard on process technology. Affected Chinese designers are generally limited to 28nm and 40nm processes, provided their chips use no high-bandwidth memory or advanced packaging, Reuters reported. One source told the agency that some Chinese AI chip designers still had access to TSMC's 7nm technology before Thursday. Reuters said it could not independently verify how those chips were made, and described the change as closing one of the last routes for Chinese companies to produce powerful AI processors.

What does the new rule actually change?

The Commerce Department's Bureau of Industry and Security published the rule, titled "Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors," in the Federal Register on Nov. 19, with immediate effect. It was first released on Nov. 16. The rule "amends the presumptions which front-end chips fabricators and chip packagers face when exporting advanced-node logic chips" and reduces "the number of pathways to overcome the presumptions for chip designers located in destinations which face a license requirement," according to the published text.

Under the existing control, a foundry must presume that any logic chip made at the 16/14nm node or below is a controlled data center AI chip unless it can prove otherwise. It had three ways to do that:

  • An attestation from an approved or authorized chip designer.
  • The foundry's own attestation that the packaged chip falls below set transistor counts — 30 billion now, 35 billion in 2027 and 40 billion from 2029 for chips without high-bandwidth memory.
  • The same attestation from an approved packaging company.

The new rule removes the second and third routes for any designer located in, or with an ultimate parent headquartered in, Country Groups D:1, D:4 or D:5, which include China, or in the newly licensed destinations. Authorized designers must be headquartered in Taiwan or close US allies and have no parent in a D:5 country. The result: Chinese designers are left needing a license. No mainland Chinese company appears on the US list of approved chip designers, which Reuters said includes Nvidia, AMD, Apple, MediaTek and Realtek.

The mechanism matters as much as the list. Reuters described the change as closing a loophole: TSMC could previously verify that certain Chinese designs fell outside US controls by checking their computing power and other traits, and can no longer do so for affected customers. In plain terms, the foundry lost its own power to vouch for a chip.

Who is affected, and how deep does it run?

Samsung's large Chinese customers include Baidu and ByteDance, and TSMC makes smartphone chips for Oppo, Vivo and Xiaomi, according to accounts of the FT report. Consumer smartphone chips would likely be approved, but the license process could delay manufacturing, the FT reported.

TSMC's guidance also tightens due diligence. The company now requires closer checks on customers' operating locations, parent companies, major shareholders, packaging providers and shipping routes, including orders placed through subsidiaries or intermediaries in Taiwan, the US, Europe, Japan and Southeast Asia, Reuters reported. Neither TSMC nor Samsung commented in the reports reviewed.

The ripple effects have already started. China's Commerce Ministry has vowed countermeasures over the rule. Malaysia told its data centers to comply, and banks paused a $480 million chip loan tied to ByteDance, Bloomberg reported.

The commercial question now is throughput: how quickly the Commerce Department issues licenses will determine whether smartphone orders keep flowing, and whether the last remaining advanced-node paths for Chinese AI silicon close for good.

mlq.ai (Source)

Filed under

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.

1,122 articles

Read also

« Previous article