Xiaomi Royalty Dispute Threatens Over $150 Mn in India Customs Claims
Indian authorities told the Supreme Court Xiaomi disclosed licensing agreements only after an import probe began; duties and penalties could exceed $150 Mn.
- By
- Sophie Lindqvist
- Filed
- Channel
- Tech Business
- Read
- 3 min read
By Sophie Lindqvist
Xiaomi's India business faces potential customs duties and penalties exceeding $150 Mn, according to a Reuters report, as the Central Government presses its case before the Supreme Court. The dispute turns on a single question: should royalty payments for imported smartphone components be counted in customs value?
The government told the court that Xiaomi produced its licensing agreements only after investigators began examining import transactions. That timing matters. Disclosure after an inquiry starts is not the same as disclosure before one, and prosecutors will draw their own conclusions from the sequence.
The dispute centres on whether royalties Xiaomi pays to technology partners belong in the assessable value of imported components for duty calculations. Xiaomi disagrees. The company maintains its contract manufacturers imported the components, and that royalty payments — estimated at 2-5% — were separate transactions outside the customs net. The claim is coherent. Whether it survives legal scrutiny is another matter.
Flex is in the frame as well. The government has challenged a separate plea from Flextronics Technologies India, the local arm of US-listed Flex, which denies helping Xiaomi undervalue imports. An Indian tax tribunal observed that contract manufacturers had willingly participated in layering transactions. In September, the government argued Flex was liable for failing to disclose the underlying contractual arrangements to customs authorities. Flex has not conceded that characterisation. Inc42 has reached out to Xiaomi for comment.
How did the dispute begin?
The current case is not the first entry in this ledger. In January 2022, the government issued three show-cause notices to Xiaomi and sought ₹653 Cr in customs duties covering April 2017 through June 2020. The notices covered roughly three years of imports. The new Supreme Court proceedings build on that foundation.
A second front opened the same year. The Enforcement Directorate seized ₹5,551 Cr from Xiaomi India's bank accounts in 2022 under FEMA provisions, alleging the company had illegally remitted funds overseas in the name of royalty payments. Xiaomi has fought that seizure. The sums at stake in the ED case dwarf the customs claim.
What else is Indian enforcement examining?
A third track emerged in September. The Serious Fraud Investigation Office reportedly recommended a detailed investigation into alleged irregularities in Xiaomi's operations and possible FEMA violations, according to press accounts. The proposed scope is broad.
The SFIO proposal reportedly covers:
- Movement of funds between Xiaomi and related entities
- Foreign investors and beneficial ownership
- Compliance with foreign direct investment rules
- Possible discrepancies in financial statements and auditor reports
The proposal also called for examining Xiaomi's relationships with sellers and ecommerce platforms. One specific concern: whether preferential and exclusive product launches on select platforms violated India's ecommerce FDI policy. None of this has resulted in findings against the company. Xiaomi has not publicly answered each item, and no adjudication has concluded.
Why does the ruling matter beyond one phone maker?
The customs case carries weight beyond Xiaomi's balance sheet. A ruling in favour of Indian authorities could invite scrutiny of royalty arrangements between companies and contract manufacturers across pharmaceuticals, automobiles and electronics manufacturing. Contract manufacturing rests on exactly this kind of licensing structure. If royalties become part of customs value, the cost base of imported-component assembly shifts for many firms, not one.
What remains unsaid is equally notable. Neither the government nor the tribunal has published a full accounting of which agreements were withheld and for how long. Xiaomi's defence rests on characterising royalties as separate transactions; the government's case rests on timing and disclosure. The Supreme Court will have to decide which framing governs. A verdict against Xiaomi would raise compliance costs across India's electronics assembly sector and give tax authorities a template for examining every royalty line in an import bill.
Source: inc42.com
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
News editor covering money, funding and market shifts around Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.
1,126 articles
Related articles
us-lawmakers-push-to-tighten-foundry-rules-on-chinese-overseas-units-6f308713
US Lawmakers Push to Tighten Foundry Rules on Chinese Overseas Units
taiwan-moves-to-criminalize-exports-of-ai-hardware-to-china-93c911c6
Taiwan Moves to Criminalize Exports of AI Hardware to China
california-man-charged-in-300-million-nvidia-server-smuggling-case-be6261bf
California Man Charged in $300 Million Nvidia Server Smuggling Case


