Steve Jobs Went Back to Apple in 1997 and $10,000 Became $18.6 Million. Jensen Huang May Be Next

Tech Business

Nvidia Weighs a Huang Return, and History Offers a Mixed Verdict

Jensen Huang has discussed returning to Nvidia after resigning Thursday, the Financial Times reported. History's founder comebacks beat the index four times out of five.

By
Nathan Brooks
Filed
Channel
Tech Business
Read
3 min read

Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia's chief executive on Thursday, and by Sunday the Financial Times reported he has discussed a return with people close to him. The stock closed Friday at $162.85, down 31.9% from its October 6 record. A retiree who held $250,000 of Nvidia at that peak now holds $170,174, exactly $79,826 less.

Neither Huang nor Nvidia has confirmed any of it. CFO Colette Kress is running the company as interim CEO, and the board has not said what its investigation found or whether it would take Huang back. Nvidia reports earnings Tuesday.

What did founder comebacks do to the stock?

The historical record is inviting but uneven. Here is what $10,000 did in each case, measured from the last close before the return news to Friday's close, counting price alone:

  • Steve Jobs, Apple, named interim CEO September 16, 1997: worth $18.6 million, a gain of 29.4% a year for 29 years. The S&P 500 fund (SPY) turned the same money into $81,554.
  • Larry Page, Google, announced January 20, 2011: worth $188,570 against $58,898 for the index.
  • Howard Schultz, Starbucks, announced January 7, 2008: worth $115,822 against $53,429.
  • Charles Schwab, announced July 20, 2004: worth $112,024 against $68,430.
  • Bob Iger, Disney, announced November 20, 2022: worth $12,960. The S&P 500 grew to $19,048.

Four of the five beat the index. Disney is the counterexample, and a useful one: Iger's Disney has gained 6.7% a year since his return while the S&P 500 gained 17.5% a year. A famous name does not repair a business by itself.

The Jobs comparison also deserves care. Apple lost more than $1 billion in its 1997 fiscal year, which is a very different starting point from a company that set a record high five weeks ago.

Does the first-day reaction predict anything?

No. Starbucks rose 8.1% the day after the Schultz announcement, Schwab rose 6.6%, Disney rose 6.3% the Monday after Iger's, Apple rose 2.0%, and Google slipped 2.4%. None of those moves predicted what followed.

Disney's pop was among the largest, and it is the one stock of the five that trailed the market. Google fell on the news and returned almost nineteen times the money.

Why is Huang's case different?

Timing, mostly. Each of those five leaders returned after someone else had run the company for at least two years. Huang resigned on Thursday, and any return would follow an unresolved investigation rather than a settled interval of someone else's leadership.

The pressure on the board is nonetheless loud. An open letter asking the board to "bring Jensen back while an independent investigation establishes the facts" had gathered more than 158,000 signatures by Sunday, according to AFP, including Elon Musk and Uber co-founder Travis Kalanick. On Friday, Altimeter's Brad Gerstner and Atreides' Gavin Baker asked the board to keep "all options" open.

What should holders actually watch?

A comeback report could move the stock either way on Monday morning, and earnings could move it again Tuesday night. Neither tells you what the company is worth in five years. Three questions matter more:

  • Concentration. A long run like Nvidia's can leave a retirement account heavier in one stock than its owner planned. If one company is a quarter of your savings, this drawdown moves the whole plan.
  • Account type. Selling inside a traditional or Roth IRA owes no tax on the sale. Selling in a taxable account can trigger a capital gains bill on years of profit, which argues for trimming in steps.
  • The honest test. Would you buy the stock today at this price? If the answer depends on whether Huang returns, you hold a bet on one board decision. Jobs and Schultz paid off. Iger did not beat the index.

The Jobs number is real, and it is also the best of five. The plan should work whether Huang comes back or not.

Source: 247wallst.com

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.

1,010 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »