Consumer TechLOT 261119 · 3 min read
UK tribunal confirms government’s Apple encryption-access order
A British tribunal confirmed that Apple received an order to bypass encryption. It rejected a national-security secrecy defense, but the broader challenge remains headed for a 2027 hearing.
Key takeaways
- Nov. 19: The tribunal confirmed that the government issued Apple a technical capability notice.
- The order required Apple to bypass encryption and provide access to customer data.
- January 2025: An initial notice sought encrypted cloud backups from US and British users; a later notice covered only UK customers.
- February 2025: Apple stopped offering Advanced Data Protection end-to-end encryption to new UK users.
- A final hearing is expected in 2027; Which? estimates 39 million to 40 million UK iCloud users.

By Grace Kim
Britain’s Investigatory Powers Tribunal confirmed on Nov. 19 that the government had issued Apple a technical capability notice requiring the company to bypass encryption and provide access to customer data. Reuters reported the decision after the tribunal rejected the government’s claim that acknowledging the order would harm national security.
The tribunal said the government "has not established that it would be damaging to national security to reveal in these proceedings" that the notice existed. That finding resolves only whether the order can be publicly acknowledged. It does not settle the government’s broader authority to issue it.
Further disclosure remains undecided. The tribunal will later determine how much of the order can be released. It also issued private judgments, which it said cannot be disclosed without damaging the public interest. The public judgment had not appeared on the tribunal’s website when MLQ.ai checked on Thursday afternoon.
What did the government order?
The sequence produced these confirmed milestones:
- January 2025: Britain issued an initial notice seeking access to encrypted cloud backups of US and British users.
- February 2025: Apple stopped offering its Advanced Data Protection end-to-end encryption to new UK users.
- After months of negotiations with the Trump administration: Britain dropped the initial notice.
- Later: Britain issued a second notice covering only Apple’s UK customers.
The two notices shifted the government’s stated customer scope from US and British users to UK customers only. The withdrawal followed months of negotiations with the Trump administration, placing the technical order within a wider U.S.-UK policy dispute.
The tribunal also cited Times and Financial Times reports that appeared to come from private media briefings provided by government officials, Reuters reported.
What remains in dispute?
Liberty and Privacy International brought the case with two individuals. They challenge the government’s power under the Investigatory Powers Act to issue technical capability notices. Such notices can require companies to change their products to enable government surveillance, including by removing or weakening encryption. Companies that receive one are legally barred from saying so publicly.
At a September case-management hearing, the applicants argued that the government should abandon its neither-confirm-nor-deny stance so the case could proceed on the actual facts. The government’s lawyer argued that dropping the policy would provide material assistance to hostile actors.
The Nov. 19 ruling rejected the secrecy defense at this stage. It did not decide the challenge to the statutory power. Apple has also launched a renewed challenge at the tribunal. Legal restrictions prevent Apple from publicly explaining the reasons for that filing.
What does the ruling mean for cloud users?
Technical capability notices can require companies to change their products to permit government surveillance. That makes the legal tool relevant to product design and feature availability, not merely access to data already stored. The initial Apple notice directly concerned encrypted cloud backups.
Liberty cited a Which? estimate that about 39 million to 40 million people in the UK use iCloud. The figure is a third-party estimate cited by Liberty, not an Apple disclosure. Apple’s February 2025 change affected new customers, while the order’s detailed terms remain secret.
Akiko Hart, Liberty’s director, said: "Today’s judgment is a victory for transparency." The British government and Apple did not immediately respond to Reuters. The final hearing in the groups’ challenge is expected in 2027.
The 2027 hearing will decide whether the government can continue using technical capability notices to force encryption changes. The outcome could shape how cloud providers design security options for British customers.
mlq.ai (Source)
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.
1,158 articles