Consumer TechLOT 261119 · 2 min read
U.K. Tribunal Orders Government to Confirm Secret Apple Backdoor Demand
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal rejected the Home Office's national security claim, forcing the first-ever confirmation of a secret technical capabilities notice served on Apple.
Key takeaways
- The Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled Thursday that the U.K. government must confirm it issued a secret encryption backdoor order to Apple.
- Apple refused the order and disabled Advanced Data Protection for iCloud for U.K. users; the order was later narrowed to British nationals' cloud data.
- Liberty International called it the first known case of the government being compelled to confirm a secret technical capabilities notice.
- A final hearing on what order details can be disclosed is expected next year.

The U.K. government must confirm it issued a secret order demanding Apple hand over encrypted customer data, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on Thursday. The decision is a rare legal rebuke for the Home Office, which argued that confirming the order's existence would damage national security.
The tribunal rejected that claim outright. It is an independent court that lets citizens challenge government surveillance orders, and its ruling forces the government onto the record for the first time.
What was the secret order?
The dispute began about a year ago, when the U.K. government reportedly demanded that Apple build a backdoor giving U.K. authorities access to customer data anywhere in the world. The demand took the form of a "technical capabilities notice," a legal instrument issued under strict non-disclosure rules that barred Apple from even acknowledging it.
Details leaked to the media anyway. The leak drew sharp criticism from White House officials and U.S. lawmakers, who argued the U.K. order would put Americans' privacy at risk.
Apple, based in California, refused to comply. Rather than build the backdoor, the company blocked U.K. users from switching on Advanced Data Protection, its end-to-end encryption feature for iCloud. The government then narrowed the order to cover data of British nationals stored in Apple's encrypted cloud. Apple challenged that second order as well.
Even after the leak, Apple remained legally barred from confirming the order existed. An Apple spokesperson did not respond to a request for comment following Thursday's ruling. The company previously said it has "never built a backdoor or master key" to any of its products or services and "never will."
A spokesperson for the Home Office, which has still not confirmed that any notice exists, also did not respond to a request for comment.
Who brought the case?
Rights group Liberty International filed the legal challenge on behalf of two individuals. The group said the ruling marks the first known occasion on which the U.K. government has been compelled to confirm the existence of a secret technical order.
That precedent matters. Technical capabilities notices operate behind a wall of legally enforced silence, and until now no recipient or challenger had broken through it in open court.
What happens next?
The tribunal has not finished its work. A final hearing on which specific details of the order can be made public is expected next year, and that hearing will determine how much of the government's encryption demand becomes visible to users, lawmakers and Apple's competitors.
For now, the secrecy barrier has a hole in it, and next year's hearing will decide whether it stays open.
techcrunch.com (Source)
More from Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in Semiconductors, chip manufacturing, hardware, AI compute at Chip Dispatch.
1,127 articles